Court orders Johannesburg to repay R12m in disputed billing
Ongoing: Gauteng water Hot
Judge Avrielle Maier-Frawley found that the city billed a student residence in Auckland Park on business tariffs and for 704 units instead of 202. She also ordered the city to pay legal costs on a punitive scale.
The Gauteng High Court in Johannesburg ruled in favour of Auckland Park Campus Apartments, which owns a student building with 982 rooms. The owner calculated overcharges of R1.4m for electricity and R12.6m for water and sewerage by May 2023. The city billed for 704 units between March 2021 and March 2022.
The court ordered the city to reverse the charges, interest, VAT and legal fees on the disputed amounts. It also ordered adjusted statements and barred the city from disconnecting services over the dispute. The city must pay costs on an attorney-and-client scale.
The judge rejected the city's argument that the owner should have applied to change from business to residential tariffs. She also rejected its argument that the owner admitted liability by signing an acknowledgement of debt for R2.5m. Reports said the owner signed it under protest and that it covered only undisputed property rates.
Maier-Frawley criticised the city's conduct in the case as obstinate. The city took 168 court days to file its notice of intention to oppose, and its answering affidavit was 70 court days late. The city blamed the delays on consultations between officials and its lawyers. The judge said an organ of state must respect court orders even if it does not agree with them.
Key facts
- Who
- Avrielle Maier-Frawley (Judge, Gauteng High Court in Johannesburg); Auckland Park Campus Apartments (property owner, owner of student accommodation building in Auckland Park); City of Johannesburg (municipality ordered to repay disputed charges)
- What
- Judge Avrielle Maier-Frawley ruled that the City of Johannesburg overbilled a student accommodation property in Auckland Park by business tariffs and an incorrect unit count, and criticised the city's conduct in the litigation as obstinate and obdurate. The court ordered the city to reverse interest, VAT and legal fees on the disputed charges and to pay costs on an attorney-and-client scale.
- When
- 18 November 2026
- Where
- Johannesburg, Auckland Park, Gauteng
- Status
- Reported