Former extradition head urges changes to new extradition bill

Advocate JJ du Toit, who once led the National Prosecuting Authority's extradition unit, told Parliament's Justice Portfolio Committee that high court judges should hear extradition cases and the justice minister needs more powers. The bill would replace a statute more than 60 years old.
Du Toit, a former deputy director of prosecutions, made his submissions on Tuesday. He said the state can benefit if a high court can also hear extradition matters. He said that in suitable cases judges, not only magistrates, can preside over extradition proceedings.
He also said the new law must state more clearly what the roles of the NPA and the justice minister are. In his view the minister should be able to send a matter back to the magistrate if new information affects the minister's decision. He added that the law should let the minister assess medical conditions independently.
Du Toit said government had learnt hard lessons in the cases it had pursued. He cited several cases as studies, including those of Moroadi Cholota, Manuel Chang, Radovan Krejcir and Fulgence Kayishema. He also cited Guus Kouwenhoven, a Dutch national who died in Cape Town after staving off extradition for nine years.
Key facts
- Who
- JJ du Toit; Justice Portfolio Committee (Parliamentary committee considering the bill); Moroadi Cholota (Former public servant whose extradition from the US was ruled unlawful by the…); Manuel Chang (Former Mozambican finance minister cited as a case study)
- What
- The Justice Portfolio Committee is considering a new extradition bill that would replace a more than 60-year-old statute. Advocate JJ du Toit, a former NPA extradition unit head, made submissions proposing changes such as allowing high courts and judges to hear extradition matters and giving the justice minister more powers.
- When
- 17 November 2026
- Where
- South Africa
- Status
- Reported